1 1379 102 DEVELOPMENTAL RELATIONSHIPS OF FOUR EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELL SUBSETS REVEALS UNDERLYING TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC LANDSCAPE CONTROL MECHANISMS. CD8(+) T CELL EXHAUSTION IS A MAJOR BARRIER TO CURRENT ANTI-CANCER IMMUNOTHERAPIES. DESPITE THIS, THE DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY OF EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELLS (TEX) REMAINS POORLY DEFINED, RESTRAINING IMPROVEMENT OF STRATEGIES AIMED AT "RE-INVIGORATING" TEX CELLS. HERE, WE DEFINED A FOUR-CELL-STAGE DEVELOPMENTAL FRAMEWORK FOR TEX CELLS. TWO TCF1(+) PROGENITOR SUBSETS WERE IDENTIFIED, ONE TISSUE RESTRICTED AND QUIESCENT AND ONE MORE BLOOD ACCESSIBLE, THAT GRADUALLY LOST TCF1 AS IT DIVIDED AND CONVERTED TO A THIRD INTERMEDIATE TEX SUBSET. THIS INTERMEDIATE SUBSET RE-ENGAGED SOME EFFECTOR BIOLOGY AND INCREASED UPON PD-L1 BLOCKADE BUT ULTIMATELY CONVERTED INTO A FOURTH, TERMINALLY EXHAUSTED SUBSET. BY USING TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC ANALYSES, WE IDENTIFIED THE CONTROL MECHANISMS UNDERLYING SUBSET TRANSITIONS AND DEFINED A KEY INTERPLAY BETWEEN TCF1, T-BET, AND TOX IN THE PROCESS. THESE DATA REVEAL A FOUR-STAGE DEVELOPMENTAL HIERARCHY FOR TEX CELLS AND DEFINE THE MOLECULAR, TRANSCRIPTIONAL, AND EPIGENETIC MECHANISMS THAT COULD PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES TO IMPROVE CANCER IMMUNOTHERAPY. 2020 2 6319 35 THE ROAD LESS TAKEN: LESS APPRECIATED PATHWAYS FOR MANIPULATING CD8(+) T CELL EXHAUSTION. EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T (TEX) CELLS ARE A DISTINCT CELL POPULATION THAT ARISE DURING PERSISTENT ANTIGEN EXPOSURE IN THE CONTEXT OF CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCERS. ALTHOUGH CHARACTERIZED BY PROGRESSIVE LOSS OF EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS, HIGH AND SUSTAINED INHIBITORY RECEPTOR EXPRESSION AND DISTINCT TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC PROGRAMS, TEX CELLS ARE HETEROGENEOUS. AMONG THESE, A SELF-RENEWING TCF-1(+) TEX POPULATION, HAVING UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS AND THE ABILITY TO RESPOND TO IMMUNE-CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE, GIVES RISE TO TCF-1(-) TERMINALLY TEX CELLS. THESE TCF-1(+) CELLS HAVE STEM CELL-LIKE PROPERTIES SIMILAR TO MEMORY T CELL POPULATIONS, BUT THE SIGNALS THAT REGULATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL PATHWAYS AND RELATIONSHIPS AMONG EXHAUSTED CELL POPULATIONS ARE STILL UNCLEAR. HERE, WE REVIEW OUR CURRENT UNDERSTANDING OF TEX CELL BIOLOGY, AND DISCUSS SOME LESS APPRECIATED MOLECULES AND PATHWAYS AFFECTING T CELL EXHAUSTION. WE HIGHLIGHT TWO CO-STIMULATORY RECEPTORS, CD226 AND CD137, AND THEIR ROLE IN INDUCING OR RESTRAINING T CELL EXHAUSTION, AS WELL AS SIGNALING PATHWAYS THAT MAY BE AMENABLE TO PHARMACOLOGICAL INHIBITION WITH A FOCUS ON PHOSPHOINOSITIDE-3 KINASE AND IL-2 PARTIAL AGONISTS. FINALLY, WE DISCUSS NOVEL METHODS THAT MAY INCREASE TCF-1(+) POPULATIONS AND THEREFORE IMPROVE IMMUNOTHERAPY RESPONSIVENESS. UNDERSTANDING FEATURES OF AND PATHWAYS TO EXHAUSTION HAS IMPORTANT IMPLICATIONS FOR THE SUCCESS OF IMMUNOTHERAPY, INCLUDING CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE AND ADOPTIVE T-CELL TRANSFER THERAPIES. 2022 3 769 32 CD8 T CELL EXHAUSTION DURING CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION AND CANCER. EXHAUSTED CD8 T (TEX) CELLS ARE A DISTINCT CELL LINEAGE THAT ARISE DURING CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCERS IN ANIMAL MODELS AND HUMANS. TEX CELLS ARE CHARACTERIZED BY PROGRESSIVE LOSS OF EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS, HIGH AND SUSTAINED INHIBITORY RECEPTOR EXPRESSION, METABOLIC DYSREGULATION, POOR MEMORY RECALL AND HOMEOSTATIC SELF-RENEWAL, AND DISTINCT TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC PROGRAMS. THE ABILITY TO REINVIGORATE TEX CELLS THROUGH INHIBITORY RECEPTOR BLOCKADE, SUCH AS ALPHAPD-1, HIGHLIGHTS THE THERAPEUTIC POTENTIAL OF TARGETING THIS POPULATION. EMERGING INSIGHTS INTO THE MECHANISMS OF EXHAUSTION ARE INFORMING IMMUNOTHERAPIES FOR CANCER AND CHRONIC INFECTIONS. HOWEVER, LIKE OTHER IMMUNE CELLS, TEX CELLS ARE HETEROGENEOUS AND INCLUDE PROGENITOR AND TERMINAL SUBSETS WITH UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS AND RESPONSES TO CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE. HERE, WE REVIEW OUR CURRENT UNDERSTANDING OF TEX CELL BIOLOGY, INCLUDING THE DEVELOPMENTAL PATHS, TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC FEATURES, AND CELL INTRINSIC AND EXTRINSIC FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EXHAUSTION AND HOW THIS KNOWLEDGE MAY INFORM THERAPEUTIC TARGETING OF TEX CELLS IN CHRONIC INFECTIONS, AUTOIMMUNITY, AND CANCER. 2019 4 2718 33 EXHAUSTED T CELLS AND EPIGENETIC STATUS. EXHAUSTED T CELLS ARE A GROUP OF DYSFUNCTIONAL T CELLS, WHICH ARE PRESENT IN CHRONIC INFECTIONS OR TUMORS. THE MOST SIGNIFICANT CHARACTERISTICS OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS ARE ATTENUATED EFFECTOR CYTOTOXICITY, REDUCED CYTOKINE PRODUCTION, AND UPREGULATION OF MULTIPLE INHIBITORY MOLECULAR RECEPTORS (E.G., PD-1, TIM-3, AND LAG-3). THE INTRACELLULAR METABOLIC CHANGES, ALTERED EXPRESSION OF TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS, AND A UNIQUE EPIGENETIC LANDSCAPE CONSTITUTE THE EXHAUSTION PROGRAM. RECENTLY, RESEARCHERS HAVE MADE PROGRESS IN UNDERSTANDING EXHAUSTED T CELLS, WITH THE DEFINITION AND IDENTIFICATION OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS CHANGING FROM PHENOTYPE-BASED TO BEING CLASSIFIED AT THE TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC LEVELS. RECENT STUDIES HAVE REVEALED THAT EXHAUSTED T CELLS CAN BE SEPARATED INTO TWO SUBGROUPS, NAMELY TCF1(+)PD-1(+) PROGENITOR-LIKE PRECURSOR EXHAUSTED CELLS AND TCF1(-)PD-1(+) TERMINALLY DIFFERENTIATED EXHAUSTED T CELLS. MOREOVER, THE PROGENITOR-LIKE PRECURSOR CELL POPULATION MAY BE A SUBSET OF T CELLS THAT CAN RESPOND TO IMMUNOTHERAPY. STUDIES HAVE ALSO FOUND THAT TOX INITIATES AND DOMINATES THE DEVELOPMENT OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS AT THE TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC LEVELS. TOX ALSO MAINTAINS T CELL SURVIVAL AND MAY AFFECT DECISIONS REGARDING TREATMENT STRATEGIES. IN THIS REVIEW, WE DISCUSS THE LATEST DEVELOPMENTS IN T CELL EXHAUSTION IN REGARDS TO DEFINITIONS, SUBPOPULATIONS, DEVELOPMENT MECHANISMS, DIFFERENCES IN DIVERSE DISEASES, AND TREATMENT PROSPECTS FOR EXHAUSTED T CELLS. FURTHERMORE, WE HYPOTHESIZE THAT THE EPIGENETIC STATE REGULATED BY TOX MIGHT BE THE KEY POINT, WHICH CAN DETERMINE THE REVERSIBILITY OF EXHAUSTION AND THE EFFICACY OF IMMUNOTHERAPY. 2020 5 2650 31 EPIGENOMIC-GUIDED MASS CYTOMETRY PROFILING REVEALS DISEASE-SPECIFIC FEATURES OF EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. EXHAUSTED CD8 T (TEX) CELLS ARE IMMUNOTHERAPY TARGETS IN CHRONIC INFECTION AND CANCER, BUT A COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT OF TEX CELL DIVERSITY IN HUMAN DISEASE IS LACKING. HERE, WE DEVELOPED A TRANSCRIPTOMIC- AND EPIGENETIC-GUIDED MASS CYTOMETRY APPROACH TO DEFINE CORE EXHAUSTION-SPECIFIC GENES AND DISEASE-INDUCED CHANGES IN TEX CELLS IN HIV AND HUMAN CANCER. SINGLE-CELL PROTEOMIC PROFILING IDENTIFIED 9 DISTINCT TEX CELL CLUSTERS USING PHENOTYPIC, FUNCTIONAL, TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR, AND INHIBITORY RECEPTOR CO-EXPRESSION PATTERNS. AN EXHAUSTION SEVERITY METRIC WAS DEVELOPED AND INTEGRATED WITH HIGH-DIMENSIONAL PHENOTYPES TO DEFINE TEX CELL CLUSTERS THAT WERE PRESENT IN HEALTHY SUBJECTS, COMMON ACROSS CHRONIC INFECTION AND CANCER OR ENRICHED IN EITHER DISEASE, LINKED TO DISEASE SEVERITY, AND CHANGED WITH HIV THERAPY. COMBINATORIAL PATTERNS OF IMMUNOTHERAPY TARGETS ON DIFFERENT TEX CELL CLUSTERS WERE ALSO DEFINED. THIS APPROACH AND ASSOCIATED DATASETS PRESENT A RESOURCE FOR INVESTIGATING HUMAN TEX CELL BIOLOGY, WITH IMPLICATIONS FOR IMMUNE MONITORING AND IMMUNOMODULATION IN CHRONIC INFECTIONS, AUTOIMMUNITY, AND CANCER. 2018 6 6060 32 THE DEVELOPMENT OF CD8 T-CELL EXHAUSTION HETEROGENEITY AND THE THERAPEUTIC POTENTIALS IN CANCER. CD8(+) T CELLS ARE ESSENTIAL LYMPHOCYTES WITH CYTOTOXIC PROPERTIES FOR ANTITUMOR IMMUNOTHERAPY. HOWEVER, DURING CHRONIC INFECTION OR TUMORIGENESIS, THESE CELLS OFTEN BECOME DYSFUNCTIONAL WITH A GRADUALLY DEPLETED ABILITY TO RELEASE CYTOKINES AND THE EXHIBITION OF REDUCED CYTOTOXICITY, THE STATE REFERRED TO AS "T-CELL EXHAUSTION" (TEX). THIS UNIQUE STATE WAS CHARACTERIZED BY THE INCREASING EXPRESSION OF INHIBITORY CHECKPOINT RECEPTORS, AND INTERVENTIONS TARGETING IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADES (ICBS) HAVE BEEN CONSIDERED AS A PROMISING STRATEGY TO STIMULATE T-CELL KILLING. RECENT INVESTIGATIONS HAVE DEMONSTRATED THAT EXHAUSTED T CELLS NOT ONLY DISPLAY FUNCTIONAL, METABOLIC, TRANSCRIPTIONAL, AND EPIGENETIC DIFFERENCES BUT ALSO COMPRISE A HETEROGENEOUS GROUP OF CELLS. IN THIS REVIEW, WE SUMMARIZE THE CURRENT FINDINGS ON DYNAMIC DIFFERENTIATION PROCESS DURING TEX HETEROGENEITY DEVELOPMENT IN CANCER AND CHRONIC INFECTION. WE DISCUSS HOW THE RESPONSES TO IMMUNOTHERAPY ARE DETERMINED BY THESE DISTINCT SUBSETS AND HIGHLIGHT PROSPECTIVE APPROACHES FOR IMPROVING THE EFFICACY OF ICB THERAPY FOR CANCER BY LEVERAGING THE HETEROGENEITY OF T CELLS. 2023 7 2410 25 EPIGENETIC SCARS OF CD8(+) T CELL EXHAUSTION PERSIST AFTER CURE OF CHRONIC INFECTION IN HUMANS. T CELL EXHAUSTION IS AN INDUCED STATE OF DYSFUNCTION THAT ARISES IN RESPONSE TO CHRONIC INFECTION AND CANCER. EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELLS ACQUIRE A DISTINCT EPIGENETIC STATE, BUT IT IS NOT KNOWN WHETHER THAT CHROMATIN LANDSCAPE IS FIXED OR PLASTIC FOLLOWING THE RESOLUTION OF A CHRONIC INFECTION. HERE WE SHOW THAT THE EPIGENETIC STATE OF EXHAUSTION IS LARGELY IRREVERSIBLE, EVEN AFTER CURATIVE THERAPY. ANALYSIS OF CHROMATIN ACCESSIBILITY IN HCV- AND HIV-SPECIFIC RESPONSES IDENTIFIES A CORE EPIGENETIC PROGRAM OF EXHAUSTION IN CD8(+) T CELLS, WHICH UNDERGOES ONLY LIMITED REMODELING BEFORE AND AFTER RESOLUTION OF INFECTION. MOREOVER, CANONICAL FEATURES OF EXHAUSTION, INCLUDING SUPER-ENHANCERS NEAR THE GENES TOX AND HIF1A, REMAIN 'EPIGENETICALLY SCARRED.' T CELL EXHAUSTION IS THEREFORE A CONSERVED EPIGENETIC STATE THAT BECOMES FIXED AND PERSISTS INDEPENDENT OF CHRONIC ANTIGEN STIMULATION AND INFLAMMATION. THERAPEUTIC EFFORTS TO REVERSE T CELL EXHAUSTION MAY REQUIRE NEW APPROACHES THAT INCREASE THE EPIGENETIC PLASTICITY OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS. 2021 8 790 24 CELLULAR AND MOLECULAR MECHANISMS OF CD8(+) T CELL DIFFERENTIATION, DYSFUNCTION AND EXHAUSTION. T CELLS FOLLOW A TRIPHASIC DISTINCT PATHWAY OF ACTIVATION, PROLIFERATION AND DIFFERENTIATION BEFORE BECOMING FUNCTIONALLY AND PHENOTYPICALLY "EXHAUSTED" IN SETTINGS OF CHRONIC INFECTION, AUTOIMMUNITY AND IN CANCER. EXHAUSTED T CELLS PROGRESSIVELY LOSE CANONICAL EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS, EXHIBIT ALTERED TRANSCRIPTIONAL NETWORKS AND EPIGENETIC SIGNATURES AND GAIN CONSTITUTIVE EXPRESSION OF A BROAD COINHIBITORY RECEPTOR SUITE. THIS REVIEW OUTLINES RECENT ADVANCES IN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF EXHAUSTED T CELL BIOLOGY AND EXAMINES CELLULAR AND MOLECULAR MECHANISMS BY WHICH A STATE OF DYSFUNCTION OR EXHAUSTION IS ESTABLISHED, AND MECHANISMS BY WHICH EXHAUSTED T CELLS MAY STILL CONTRIBUTE TO PATHOGEN OR TUMOUR CONTROL. FURTHER, THIS REVIEW DESCRIBES OUR UNDERSTANDING OF EXHAUSTED T CELL HETEROGENEITY AND OUTLINES THE MECHANISMS BY WHICH CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE DIFFERENTIALLY ENGAGES EXHAUSTED T CELL SUBSETS TO OVERCOME EXHAUSTION AND RECOVER T CELL FUNCTION. 2020 9 3288 31 HIERARCHICAL TRANSCRIPTIONAL NETWORK GOVERNING HETEROGENEOUS T CELL EXHAUSTION AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE. THE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE OF IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE (ICB) IS TO PROTECT TUMOR-INFILTRATING T CELLS FROM BEING EXHAUSTED. DESPITE THE REMARKABLE SUCCESS ACHIEVED BY ICB TREATMENT, ONLY A SMALL GROUP OF PATIENTS BENEFIT FROM IT. CHARACTERIZED BY A HYPOFUNCTIONAL STATE WITH THE EXPRESSION OF MULTIPLE INHIBITORY RECEPTORS, EXHAUSTED T (TEX) CELLS ARE A MAJOR OBSTACLE IN IMPROVING ICB. T CELL EXHAUSTION IS A PROGRESSIVE PROCESS WHICH ADAPTS TO PERSISTENT ANTIGEN STIMULATION IN CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCERS. IN THIS REVIEW, WE ELUCIDATE THE HETEROGENEITY OF TEX CELLS AND OFFER NEW INSIGHTS INTO THE HIERARCHICAL TRANSCRIPTIONAL REGULATION OF T CELL EXHAUSTION. FACTORS AND SIGNALING PATHWAYS THAT INDUCE AND PROMOTE EXHAUSTION ARE ALSO SUMMARIZED. MOREOVER, WE REVIEW THE EPIGENETIC AND METABOLIC ALTERATIONS OF TEX CELLS AND DISCUSS HOW PD-1 SIGNALING AFFECTS THE BALANCE BETWEEN T CELL ACTIVATION AND EXHAUSTION, AIMING TO PROVIDE MORE THERAPEUTIC TARGETS FOR APPLICATIONS OF COMBINATIONAL IMMUNOTHERAPIES. 2023 10 5895 16 T CELL EXHAUSTION: AN EPIGENETICALLY IMPRINTED PHENOTYPIC AND FUNCTIONAL MAKEOVER. A RECENT ARTICLE IN CELL DEMONSTRATES THAT THE ABSENCE OF A SINGLE DNA METHYLTRANSFERASE, DNMT3A, PREVENTS CYTOTOXIC T CELLS FROM ACQUIRING THE HYPOFUNCTIONAL OR EXHAUSTED PHENOTYPE TYPICALLY SEEN IN CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTIONS AND TUMORS. UPON ESTABLISHING A CAUSAL RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN EXHAUSTION-ASSOCIATED EPIGENETIC CHANGES AND REDUCED CD8(+) T CELL FUNCTION, THE AUTHORS PROVIDED MECHANISTIC EVIDENCE THAT EXHAUSTION CONSTITUTES A SPECIFIC DIFFERENTIATION PROGRAM. 2017 11 6530 28 TRANSCRIPTIONAL REGULATION AND T CELL EXHAUSTION. PURPOSE OF REVIEW: THIS REVIEW HIGHLIGHTS THE CONTROL OF TRANSCRIPTIONAL NETWORKS, INCLUDING INDUCTION OF INHIBITORY RECEPTORS, BY T CELL-SPECIFIC TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS IN EXHAUSTED T CELLS THAT ACCUMULATE IN CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTIONS INCLUDING HIV. RECENT FINDINGS: TRANSCRIPTIONAL PROFILING HAS ESTABLISHED DISTINCT MOLECULAR PHENOTYPES FOR EXHAUSTED CD4 AND CD8 T CELLS IN CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION MODELS. THERE EXISTS A SUBSET OF TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH EXHAUSTION, NOTABLY BLIMP-1, BASIC LEUCINE ZIPPER TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR, ATF-LIKE AND HELIOS. EPIGENETIC PHENOMENA ARE LIKELY IMPORTANT IN REGULATING GENE EXPRESSION NETWORKS DURING EXHAUSTION AS ILLUSTRATED BY PROGRAMMED DEATH 1 PROMOTER METHYLATION PATTERNS. SUMMARY: FOLLOWING CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTIONS, CD4 AND CD8 T CELLS DEFINED FUNCTIONALLY AND PHENOTYPICALLY AS EXHAUSTED HAVE DISTINCT TRANSCRIPTIONAL PROFILES. THESE STUDIES HAVE IDENTIFIED A CORE SET OF TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS THAT HAVE BEEN IMPLICATED IN PROMOTING EXHAUSTION. HOWEVER, NO SINGLE FACTOR APPEARS TO BE AN EXHAUSTION DETERMINING FACTOR, SUGGESTING THAT T CELL EXHAUSTION REFLECTS A COMBINATORIAL MECHANISM WITH MULTIPLE TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS INTERACTING TO INFLUENCE THE DEVELOPMENT OF FUNCTIONALLY EXHAUSTED T CELLS AS WELL AS DIFFERENT T EFFECTOR POPULATIONS. 2014 12 1306 32 DEFINING 'T CELL EXHAUSTION'. 'T CELL EXHAUSTION' IS A BROAD TERM THAT HAS BEEN USED TO DESCRIBE THE RESPONSE OF T CELLS TO CHRONIC ANTIGEN STIMULATION, FIRST IN THE SETTING OF CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION BUT MORE RECENTLY IN RESPONSE TO TUMOURS. UNDERSTANDING THE FEATURES OF AND PATHWAYS TO EXHAUSTION HAS CRUCIAL IMPLICATIONS FOR THE SUCCESS OF CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE AND ADOPTIVE T CELL TRANSFER THERAPIES. IN THIS VIEWPOINT ARTICLE, 18 EXPERTS IN THE FIELD TELL US WHAT EXHAUSTION MEANS TO THEM, RANGING FROM COMPLETE LACK OF EFFECTOR FUNCTION TO ALTERED FUNCTIONALITY TO PREVENT IMMUNOPATHOLOGY, WITH POTENTIAL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN CANCER AND CHRONIC INFECTION. THEIR RESPONSES HIGHLIGHT THE DICHOTOMY BETWEEN TERMINALLY DIFFERENTIATED EXHAUSTED T CELLS THAT ARE TCF1(-) AND THE SELF-RENEWING TCF1(+) POPULATION FROM WHICH THEY DERIVE. THESE TCF1(+) CELLS ARE CONSIDERED BY SOME TO HAVE STEM CELL-LIKE PROPERTIES AKIN TO MEMORY T CELL POPULATIONS, BUT THE DEVELOPMENTAL RELATIONSHIPS ARE UNCLEAR AT PRESENT. RECENT STUDIES HAVE ALSO HIGHLIGHTED AN IMPORTANT ROLE FOR THE TRANSCRIPTIONAL REGULATOR TOX IN DRIVING THE EPIGENETIC ENFORCEMENT OF EXHAUSTION, BUT KEY QUESTIONS REMAIN ABOUT THE POTENTIAL TO REVERSE THE EPIGENETIC PROGRAMME OF EXHAUSTION AND HOW THIS MIGHT AFFECT THE PERSISTENCE OF T CELL POPULATIONS. 2019 13 771 31 CD8(+) T CELL EXHAUSTION. CD8(+) T CELLS ARE IMPORTANT FOR THE PROTECTIVE IMMUNITY AGAINST INTRACELLULAR PATHOGENS AND TUMOR. IN THE CASE OF CHRONIC INFECTION OR CANCER, CD8(+) T CELLS ARE EXPOSED TO PERSISTENT ANTIGEN AND/OR INFLAMMATORY SIGNALS. THIS EXCESSIVE AMOUNT OF SIGNALS OFTEN LEADS CD8(+) T CELLS TO GRADUAL DETERIORATION OF T CELL FUNCTION, A STATE CALLED "EXHAUSTION." EXHAUSTED T CELLS ARE CHARACTERIZED BY PROGRESSIVE LOSS OF EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS (CYTOKINE PRODUCTION AND KILLING FUNCTION), EXPRESSION OF MULTIPLE INHIBITORY RECEPTORS (SUCH AS PD-1 AND LAG3), DYSREGULATED METABOLISM, POOR MEMORY RECALL RESPONSE, AND HOMEOSTATIC PROLIFERATION. THESE ALTERED FUNCTIONS ARE CLOSELY RELATED WITH ALTERED TRANSCRIPTIONAL PROGRAM AND EPIGENETIC LANDSCAPE THAT CLEARLY DISTINGUISH EXHAUSTED T CELLS FROM NORMAL EFFECTOR AND MEMORY T CELLS. T CELL EXHAUSTION IS OFTEN ASSOCIATED WITH INEFFICIENT CONTROL OF PERSISTING INFECTIONS AND CANCERS, BUT RE-INVIGORATION OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS WITH INHIBITORY RECEPTOR BLOCKADE CAN PROMOTE IMPROVED IMMUNITY AND DISEASE OUTCOME. ACCUMULATING EVIDENCES SUPPORT THE THERAPEUTIC POTENTIAL OF TARGETING EXHAUSTED T CELLS. HOWEVER, EXHAUSTED T CELLS COMPRISE HETEROGENOUS CELL POPULATION WITH DISTINCT RESPONSIVENESS TO INTERVENTION. UNDERSTANDING MOLECULAR MECHANISM OF T CELL EXHAUSTION IS ESSENTIAL TO ESTABLISH RATIONAL IMMUNOTHERAPEUTIC INTERVENTIONS. 2019 14 5248 29 PROGRAMMED CELL DEATH 1-DIRECTED IMMUNOTHERAPY FOR ENHANCING T-CELL FUNCTION. T-CELL EXHAUSTION IS A UNIQUE STATE THAT APPEARS DURING MANY CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCER AND IS CHARACTERIZED BY LOSS OF PROLIFERATIVE CAPACITY AND EFFECTOR FUNCTION. COMPLEX MECHANISMS ARE INVOLVED IN THIS T-CELL DYSFUNCTION BUT AN INHIBITORY RECEPTOR, PD-1, HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED AS A MAJOR REGULATOR OF T-CELL EXHAUSTION. BLOCKADE OF THE PD-1 PATHWAY CAN REINVIGORATE EXHAUSTED T CELLS, RESULTING IN BETTER CONTROL OF CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCER. NOTABLY, RECENT CLINICAL STUDIES HAVE REVEALED THAT PD-1-DIRECTED IMMUNOTHERAPY IS HIGHLY EFFECTIVE IN CANCER PATIENTS, DEMONSTRATING THAT PD-1 IS A PROMISING THERAPEUTIC TARGET IN HUMANS. IN THIS REVIEW, WE SUMMARIZE OUR CURRENT UNDERSTANDING OF THE EPIGENETIC REGULATION OF PD-1 EXPRESSION IN T CELLS AND DISCUSS POTENTIAL COMBINATION THERAPY WITH PD-1 BLOCKADE TOWARD DEVELOPING MORE EFFECTIVE TREATMENT FOR CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCER. 2013 15 5704 29 SINGLE-CELL RNA-SEQ REVEALS TOX AS A KEY REGULATOR OF CD8(+) T CELL PERSISTENCE IN CHRONIC INFECTION. PROGENITOR-LIKE CD8(+) T CELLS MEDIATE LONG-TERM IMMUNITY TO CHRONIC INFECTION AND CANCER AND RESPOND POTENTLY TO IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE. THESE CELLS SHARE TRANSCRIPTIONAL REGULATORS WITH MEMORY PRECURSOR CELLS, INCLUDING T CELL-SPECIFIC TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR 1 (TCF1), BUT IT IS UNCLEAR WHETHER THEY ADOPT DISTINCT PROGRAMS TO ADAPT TO THE IMMUNOSUPPRESSIVE ENVIRONMENT. BY COMPARING THE SINGLE-CELL TRANSCRIPTOMES AND EPIGENETIC PROFILES OF CD8(+) T CELLS RESPONDING TO ACUTE AND CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTIONS, WE FOUND THAT PROGENITOR-LIKE CD8(+) T CELLS BECAME DISTINCT FROM MEMORY PRECURSOR CELLS BEFORE THE PEAK OF THE T CELL RESPONSE. WE DISCOVERED A COEXPRESSION GENE MODULE CONTAINING TOX THAT EXHIBITED HIGHER TRANSCRIPTIONAL ACTIVITY ASSOCIATED WITH MORE ABUNDANT ACTIVE HISTONE MARKS IN PROGENITOR-LIKE CELLS THAN MEMORY PRECURSOR CELLS. MOREOVER, THYMOCYTE SELECTION-ASSOCIATED HIGH MOBILITY GROUP BOX PROTEIN TOX (TOX) PROMOTED THE PERSISTENCE OF ANTIVIRAL CD8(+) T CELLS AND WAS REQUIRED FOR THE PROGRAMMING OF PROGENITOR-LIKE CD8(+) T CELLS. THUS, LONG-TERM CD8(+) T CELL IMMUNITY TO CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION REQUIRES UNIQUE TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC PROGRAMS ASSOCIATED WITH THE TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR TOX. 2019 16 2421 34 EPIGENETIC SIGNATURE OF PD-1+ TCF1+ CD8 T CELLS THAT ACT AS RESOURCE CELLS DURING CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION AND RESPOND TO PD-1 BLOCKADE. WE HAVE RECENTLY DEFINED A NOVEL POPULATION OF PD-1 (PROGRAMMED CELL DEATH 1)+ TCF1 (T CELL FACTOR 1)+ VIRUS-SPECIFIC CD8 T CELLS THAT FUNCTION AS RESOURCE CELLS DURING CHRONIC LCMV INFECTION AND PROVIDE THE PROLIFERATIVE BURST SEEN AFTER PD-1 BLOCKADE. SUCH CD8 T CELLS HAVE BEEN FOUND IN OTHER CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND ALSO IN CANCER IN MICE AND HUMANS. THESE CD8 T CELLS EXHIBIT STEM-LIKE PROPERTIES UNDERGOING SELF-RENEWAL AND ALSO DIFFERENTIATING INTO THE TERMINALLY EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. HERE WE COMPARED THE EPIGENETIC SIGNATURE OF STEM-LIKE CD8 T CELLS WITH EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. ATAC-SEQ ANALYSIS SHOWED THAT STEM-LIKE CD8 T CELLS HAD A UNIQUE SIGNATURE IMPLICATING ACTIVITY OF HMG (TCF) AND RHD (NF-KAPPAB) TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR FAMILY MEMBERS IN CONTRAST TO HIGHER ACCESSIBILITY TO ETS AND RUNX MOTIFS IN EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. IN ADDITION, REGULATORY REGIONS OF THE TRANSCRIPTION FACTORS TCF7 AND ID3 WERE MORE ACCESSIBLE IN STEM-LIKE CELLS WHEREAS PRDM1 AND ID2 WERE MORE ACCESSIBLE IN EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. WE ALSO COMPARED THE EPIGENETIC SIGNATURES OF THE 2 CD8 T CELL SUBSETS FROM CHRONICALLY INFECTED MICE WITH EFFECTOR AND MEMORY CD8 T CELLS GENERATED AFTER AN ACUTE LCMV INFECTION. BOTH CD8 T CELL SUBSETS GENERATED DURING CHRONIC INFECTION WERE STRIKINGLY DIFFERENT FROM CD8 T CELL SUBSETS FROM ACUTE INFECTION. INTERESTINGLY, THE STEM-LIKE CD8 T CELL SUBSET FROM CHRONIC INFECTION, DESPITE SHARING KEY FUNCTIONAL PROPERTIES WITH MEMORY CD8 T CELLS, HAD A VERY DISTINCT EPIGENETIC PROGRAM. THESE RESULTS SHOW THAT THE CHRONIC STEM-LIKE CD8 T CELL PROGRAM REPRESENTS A SPECIFIC ADAPTATION OF THE T CELL RESPONSE TO PERSISTENT ANTIGENIC STIMULATION. 2019 17 4178 24 MEMORY T-CELL HETEROGENEITY AND TERMINOLOGY. IMMUNOLOGICAL MEMORY AND EXHAUSTION ARE FUNDAMENTAL FEATURES OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY. RECENT ADVANCES REVEAL INCREASING HETEROGENEITY AND DIVERSITY AMONG CD8 T-CELL SUBSETS, RESULTING IN NEW SUBSETS TO ANNOTATE AND UNDERSTAND. HERE, WE REVIEW OUR CURRENT KNOWLEDGE OF DIFFERENTIATION AND MAINTENANCE OF MEMORY AND EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS, INCLUDING PHENOTYPIC CLASSIFICATION, DEVELOPMENTAL PATHS, TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC FEATURES, AND CELL INTRINSIC AND EXTRINSIC FACTORS. ADDITIONALLY, WE USE THIS OUTLINE TO DISCUSS THE NOMENCLATURE OF EFFECTOR, MEMORY, AND EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS. FINALLY, WE DISCUSS HOW NEW FINDINGS ABOUT THESE CELL TYPES MAY IMPACT THE THERAPEUTIC EFFICACY AND DEVELOPMENT OF IMMUNOTHERAPIES TARGETING EFFECTOR, MEMORY, AND/OR EXHAUSTED CD8 T CELLS IN CHRONIC INFECTIONS AND CANCER. 2021 18 6121 25 THE EPIGENETIC LANDSCAPE OF T CELL EXHAUSTION. EXHAUSTED T CELLS IN CANCER AND CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION EXPRESS DISTINCTIVE PATTERNS OF GENES, INCLUDING SUSTAINED EXPRESSION OF PROGRAMMED CELL DEATH PROTEIN 1 (PD-1). HOWEVER, THE REGULATION OF GENE EXPRESSION IN EXHAUSTED T CELLS IS POORLY UNDERSTOOD. HERE, WE DEFINE THE ACCESSIBLE CHROMATIN LANDSCAPE IN EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELLS AND SHOW THAT IT IS DISTINCT FROM FUNCTIONAL MEMORY CD8(+) T CELLS. EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELLS IN HUMANS AND A MOUSE MODEL OF CHRONIC VIRAL INFECTION ACQUIRE A STATE-SPECIFIC EPIGENETIC LANDSCAPE ORGANIZED INTO FUNCTIONAL MODULES OF ENHANCERS. GENOME EDITING SHOWS THAT PD-1 EXPRESSION IS REGULATED IN PART BY AN EXHAUSTION-SPECIFIC ENHANCER THAT CONTAINS ESSENTIAL RAR, T-BET, AND SOX3 MOTIFS. FUNCTIONAL ENHANCER MAPS MAY OFFER TARGETS FOR GENOME EDITING THAT ALTER GENE EXPRESSION PREFERENTIALLY IN EXHAUSTED CD8(+) T CELLS. 2016 19 6851 29 [MOLECULAR PROFILES OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS AND THEIR IMPACT ON RESPONSE TO IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE]. T CELL EXHAUSTION IS INDUCED IN THE CONTEXT OF CHRONIC VIRUS INFECTION AND TUMOR MICROENVIRONMENT, IN WHICH CYTOTOXIC T CELLS ARE REPEATEDLY EXPOSED TO THE TARGET ANTIGEN AND DEPRIVED OF THEIR EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS. MULTIPLE STUDIES HAVE ALREADY SHOWN THE SIGNIFICANT IMPACT OF IMMUNE CHECKPOINT MOLECULES SUCH AS PD1 ON FUNCTIONAL PROPERTIES OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS. IN ADDITION TO THESE SIGNALS, EXHAUSTED T CELLS POSSESS DISTINCT TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC PROFILES COMPARED WITH CONVENTIONAL EFFECTOR AND MEMORY T CELLS. IMPORTANTLY, MOST OF THESE FEATURES ARE NOT AFFECTED BY IMMUNE CHECKPOINT BLOCKADE, SUGGESTING THAT GENETIC AND EPIGENETIC REMODELING OF T CELLS IS AN UNDERLYING MOLECULAR MECHANISM ESSENTIAL FOR T CELL EXHAUSTION. MOREOVER, IT HAS NOW BEEN EVIDENT THAT EXHAUSTED T CELLS ARE A HETEROGENEOUS CELL POPULATION COMPOSED OF DISTINCT T CELL SUBSETS, AND THESE FUNCTIONAL DIFFERENCES PROFOUNDLY AFFECT THERAPEUTIC EFFICACY OF CANCER IMMUNOTHERAPY. IN THIS REVIEW, I WILL DISCUSS RECENT STUDIES INVESTIGATING MOLECULAR MECHANISMS OF T CELL EXHAUSTION, INCLUDING NOVEL KEY MOLECULES ESSENTIALLY ASSOCIATED WITH T CELL EXHAUSTION. THESE FINDINGS ARE POTENTIALLY APPLICABLE TO REINVIGORATE EFFECTOR FUNCTIONS OF EXHAUSTED T CELLS. 2022 20 5620 37 SCHRODINGER'S T CELLS: MOLECULAR INSIGHTS INTO STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION. T CELL STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION COEXIST AS TWO KEY CONTRASTING PHENOMENA DURING CHRONIC ANTIGEN STIMULATION, SUCH AS INFECTION, TRANSPLANT, CANCER, AND AUTOIMMUNITY. T CELL EXHAUSTION REFERS TO THE PROGRESSIVE LOSS OF EFFECTOR FUNCTION CAUSED BY CHRONIC ANTIGEN EXPOSURE. EXHAUSTED T (T(EX)) CELLS HIGHLY EXPRESS MULTIPLE INHIBITORY RECEPTORS AND EXHIBIT SEVERE DEFECTS IN CELL PROLIFERATION AND CYTOKINE PRODUCTION. THE TERM T CELL STEMNESS DESCRIBES THE STEM CELL-LIKE BEHAVIORS OF T CELLS, INCLUDING SELF-RENEWAL, MULTIPOTENCY, AND FUNCTIONAL PERSISTENCE. IT IS WELL ACCEPTED THAT NAIVE AND SOME MEMORY T CELL SUBSETS HAVE STEM CELL-LIKE PROPERTIES. WHEN INVESTIGATING THE EXHAUSTIVE DIFFERENTIATION OF T CELLS IN CHRONIC INFECTION AND CANCER, RECENT STUDIES HIGHLIGHTED THE STEMNESS OF "PRECURSORS OF EXHAUSTED" T (T(PEX)) CELLS PRIOR TO THEIR TERMINAL DIFFERENTIATION TO T(EX) CELLS. CLINICALLY SUCCESSFUL CHECKPOINT BLOCKADES FOR CANCER TREATMENT APPEAR TO INVIGORATE ANTITUMOR T(PEX) CELLS BUT NOT T(EX) CELLS. HERE WE DISCUSS THE TRANSCRIPTIONAL AND EPIGENETIC REGULATIONS OF T CELL STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION, WITH A FOCUS ON HOW SYSTEMS IMMUNOLOGY WAS AND WILL BE UTILIZED TO DEFINE THE MOLECULAR BASIS UNDERLYING THE TRANSITION OF T(PEX) TO T(EX) CELLS. WE SUGGEST A "STEPWISE MODEL" OF T CELL STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION, IN WHICH LOSS OF STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION PROGRESSION ARE GRADUAL MULTI-STEP PROCESSES. WE PROVIDE PERSPECTIVES ON THE RESEARCH NEEDED TO DEFINE T CELL STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION IN THE TRANSPLANTATION SETTING, IN WHICH ALLOGENIC T CELLS ARE ALSO CHRONICALLY EXPOSED TO ALLOANTIGENS. A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF T CELL STEMNESS AND EXHAUSTION WILL SHED LIGHT ON DEVELOPING NOVEL STRATEGIES FOR IMMUNOTHERAPIES. 2021